Revision as of 14:32, 7 April 2019

Summary of the Sokoban Revenge level set

Each solver is tested separately to ensure that they don't compete for system resources.

Though some people might be interested in how long it takes to solve a given level and/or how good the solution is (optimal or not),
this summary disregards all timing associated with solving the levels and solution statistics.

These tests are mainly for gauging solvability, not timing nor how good the solution is.

All solvers combined solved 258 of 306 levels.

All solvers 84%

Summary in a table

Solver Statistics Set: Sokoban Revenge
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
1						no	yes	no
2						no	yes	no
3						no	yes	no
4						no	no	no
5						no	no	no
6						no	yes	no
7						no	yes	no
8						no	yes	no
9						no	yes	no
10						no	yes	no
11						no	yes	no
12						no	yes	no
13						no	yes	no
14						no	yes	no
15						no	yes	no
16						no	yes	no
17						no	no	no
18						no	yes	no
19						no	yes	no
20						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
21						no	no	no
22						no	yes	no
23						no	yes	no
24						no	yes	no
25						no	yes	no
26						no	yes	no
27						no	yes	no
28						no	no	no
29						no	no	no
30						no	yes	no
31						no	yes	no
32						no	yes	no
33						no	no	no
34						no	no	no
35						no	yes	no
36						no	no	no
37						no	yes	no
38						no	yes	no
39						no	yes	no
40						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
41						no	no	no
42						no	yes	no
43						no	yes	no
44						no	no	no
45						no	no	no
46						no	yes	no
47						no	yes	no
48						no	no	no
49						no	yes	no
50						no	yes	no
51						no	no	no
52						no	no	no
53						no	no	no
54						no	no	no
55						no	no	no
56						no	no	no
57						yes	no	no
58						no	no	no
59						no	no	no
60						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
61						no	no	no
62						no	no	no
63						no	no	no
64						no	no	no
65						no	no	no
66						no	no	no
67						no	no	no
68						yes	no	no
69						no	no	no
70						yes	no	no
71						yes	no	no
72						no	no	no
73						no	no	no
74						yes	no	no
75						yes	no	no
76						no	no	no
77						no	no	no
78						no	no	yes
79						no	no	yes
80						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
81						no	no	no
82						no	no	no
83						no	no	no
84						no	no	no
85						no	yes	no
86						no	yes	no
87						no	no	no
88						no	no	no
89						no	no	yes
90						no	no	no
91						no	no	no
92						no	no	no
93						no	no	no
94						no	no	no
95						no	no	no
96						no	no	no
97						no	no	no
98						no	no	no
99						no	no	no
100						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
101						no	no	no
102						no	yes	no
103						no	yes	no
104						no	yes	no
105						no	no	no
106						no	no	no
107						no	no	no
108						no	yes	no
109						no	no	no
110						no	yes	no
111						no	no	no
112						no	no	no
113						no	no	no
114						no	no	no
115						no	no	no
116						no	no	yes
117						no	yes	no
118						no	no	yes
119						no	yes	no
120						no	yes	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
121						no	no	no
122						no	no	no
123						no	no	no
124						yes	no	no
125						no	no	yes
126						no	no	no
127						no	no	no
128						no	yes	no
129						no	no	no
130						no	yes	no
131						no	no	no
132						no	yes	no
133						no	no	no
134						no	no	yes
135						no	yes	no
136						no	no	no
137						yes	no	no
138						yes	no	no
139						no	no	yes
140						no	no	yes
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
141						no	no	no
142						yes	no	no
143						no	no	no
144						no	no	no
145						no	no	no
146						no	no	no
147						yes	no	no
148						no	no	no
149						no	yes	no
150						yes	no	no
151						no	no	no
152						no	no	no
153						no	no	no
154						no	no	yes
155						yes	no	no
156						no	no	no
157						no	no	no
158						no	yes	no
159						no	no	no
160						no	yes	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
161						no	no	no
162						no	no	no
163						no	no	no
164						no	no	no
165						no	no	no
166						yes	no	no
167						no	no	no
168						no	no	no
169						no	no	no
170						no	no	no
171						no	no	no
172						no	no	no
173						no	no	no
174						no	no	no
175						no	no	no
176						no	no	no
177						no	no	no
178						no	no	no
179						no	no	no
180						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
181						no	no	no
182						no	no	yes
183						no	no	no
184						no	no	no
185						no	yes	no
186						yes	no	no
187						no	no	no
188						yes	no	no
189						no	no	yes
190						yes	no	no
191						no	no	no
192						no	yes	no
193						no	yes	no
194						no	no	no
195						no	no	no
196						yes	no	no
197						no	no	no
198						no	no	no
199						no	no	no
200						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
201						no	no	no
202						no	no	no
203						no	no	yes
204						no	no	yes
205						no	no	no
206						no	no	no
207						no	no	no
208						no	yes	no
209						no	no	no
210						no	no	no
211						no	yes	no
212						no	no	no
213						yes	no	no
214						yes	no	no
215						no	no	no
216						no	no	no
217						no	no	no
218						no	no	no
219						yes	no	no
220						no	no	yes
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
221						no	no	no
222						no	yes	no
223						no	no	no
224						no	no	no
225						no	yes	no
226						no	yes	no
227						no	yes	no
228						no	no	yes
229						no	no	no
230						no	no	yes
231						no	no	yes
232						no	no	no
233						no	yes	no
234						no	no	yes
235						no	no	no
236						no	no	yes
237						no	no	no
238						no	no	yes
239						yes	no	no
240						no	no	yes
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
241						no	no	no
242						no	no	no
243						no	no	no
244						no	no	yes
245						no	no	no
246						no	no	no
247						no	no	no
248						no	no	no
249						yes	no	no
250						yes	no	no
251						no	no	yes
252						yes	no	no
253						no	no	no
254						no	no	no
255						no	no	no
256						no	no	no
257						no	no	no
258						no	no	no
259						no	no	yes
260						yes	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
261						no	no	no
262						no	no	no
263						no	no	no
264						no	no	yes
265						yes	no	no
266						no	no	yes
267						no	no	yes
268						no	no	no
269						no	yes	no
270						no	no	no
271						no	no	yes
272						no	yes	no
273						no	no	yes
274						no	no	yes
275						no	no	no
276						no	no	yes
277						no	yes	no
278						no	yes	no
279						no	no	yes
280						no	yes	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
281						no	no	yes
282						no	no	yes
283						no	no	yes
284						no	no	yes
285						no	yes	no
286						no	yes	no
287						no	no	yes
288						no	no	no
289						no	no	yes
290						no	no	no
291						no	no	yes
292						no	no	yes
293						yes	no	no
294						no	no	no
295						no	no	yes
296						yes	no	no
297						no	no	yes
298						no	yes	no
299						no	yes	no
300						no	no	no
LevelNo	BoxSearch	Takaken	YASS	JSoko	Sokolution	Solved by only one	Solved by all	Solved by none
301						no	no	yes
302						no	no	no
303						no	no	yes
304						no	no	yes
305						no	no	yes
306						no	no	yes
Total	76	244	194	171	203	29	71	48

Original summary results by Ming

The following table shows the levels where each of the solvers failed:
======================================================================

          BOXSEARCH             JSOKO          Sokolution_v301         Takaken               YASS        
    ==================    ==================  ==================   ==================  ==================
            4                                                                                  4             
            5                                                                                                         
           17                                                                                                         
           20                                                                                                         
           21                                                                                                         
           28                                                                                                         
           29                                                                                                         
           33                                                                                                         
           34                                                                                                         
           36                                                                                                         
           40                                                                                                         
           41                                                                                                         
           44                     44                                                          44             
           45                                                                                                         
           48                     48                                                                                  
           51                     51                                                                                  
           52                                                                                                         
           53                                                                                                         
           54                                                                                                         
           55                     55                  55                                                           
           56                                         56                                                           
           57                     57                                       57                 57             
           58                                                                                                         
           59                                                                                                         
           60                     60                                                                                  
           61                                         61                                                           
           62                     62                  62                                                           
           63                                                                                                         
           64                     64                                                                                  
           65                     65                  65                                                           
           66                     66                  66                                                           
           67                     67                                                                                  
           68                     68                  68                                      68             
           69                                                                                                         
           70                     70                  70                                      70             
           71                     71                  71                   71                                    
           72                     72                                                                                  
           73                                                                                                         
           74                     74                  74                                      74             
           75                     75                  75                                      75             
           76                     76                  76                                                           
           77                                                                                 77             
           78                     78                  78                   78                 78             
           79                     79                  79                   79                 79             
                                                      80                                                           
                                                      81                                                           
                                                      82                                                           
                                                      83                                                           
                                                      84                                                           
           87                                                                                                         
           88                     88                                                          88             
           89                     89                  89                   89                 89             
           90                     90                  90                                                           
           91                     91                                                          91             
           92                     92                                                                                  
           93                                                                                                         
           94                                                                                                         
           95                                                                                                         
           96                                                                                                         
           97                     97                                                          97             
           98                                         98                                                           
           99                                         99                                                           
          100                                                                                                         
          101                                        101                                     101             
          105                    105                                                         105             
          106                                                                                106             
          107                    107                                                                                  
          109                                                                                                         
          111                    111                                                                                  
          112                    112                                                         112             
          113                    113                                                                                  
          114                                                                                                         
          115                                                                                                         
          116                    116                 116                  116                116             
          118                    118                 118                  118                118             
          121                                        121                                                          
          122                                                                                                         
          123                                                                                                       
          124                    124                 124                  124                                    
          125                    125                 125                  125                125            
          126                                                                                                         
          127                                                                                                         
          129                                                                                129             
          131                                                                                                         
          133                                                                                                         
          134                    134                 134                  134                134             
          136                                                                                                       
          137                    137                 137                                     137             
          138                    138                 138                                     138             
          139                    139                 139                  139                139             
          140                    140                 140                  140                140             
          141                    141                                                         141             
          142                    142                 142                                     142             
          143                                                                                                         
          144                                        144                                                           
          145                                                                                                         
          146                    146                 146                                                           
          147                    147                 147                  147                                    
          148                                                                                                         
          150                    150                                      150                150             
          151                                        151                                                           
          152                                                                                                         
          153                                                                                                         
          154                    154                 154                  154                154             
          155                    155                 155                                     155             
          156                                                                                                         
          157                    157                                                         157             
          159                    159                                                                                  
          161                                                                                                         
          162                                        162                  162                                    
          163                                                                                                         
          164                                                                                                         
          165                    165                                                                                  
          166                    166                 166                                     166             
          167                                                                                                         
          168                    168                                                         168             
          169                                                                                169             
          170                                                                                170             
          171                                                                                171             
          172                    172                                                         172             
          173                    173                                                                                  
          174                                                                                174             
          175                    175                 175                                                           
          176                                                                                                         
          177                    177                                                         177             
          178                    178                                                         178             
          179                    179                 179                                                           
          180                    180                                                         180             
          181                    181                                                                                  
          182                    182                 182                  182                182             
          183                    183                                                         183             
          184                    184                                                                                  
          186                    186                 186                                     186             
          187                    187                 187                                                           
          188                    188                 188                                     188             
          189                    189                 189                  189                189             
          190                    190                 190                                     190             
          191                    191                                                         191             
          194                    194                 194                                                           
          195                    195                 195                                                           
          196                    196                                      196                196             
          197                                                                                                         
          198                                                                                                         
          199                                                                                                         
          200                                                                                                         
          201                                                                                                         
          202                                        202                                                           
          203                    203                 203                  203                203             
          204                    204                 204                  204                204             
          205                    205                                                         205             
          206                    206                 206                                                           
          207                                                                                                         
          209                    209                                                                                  
          210                                                                                                         
          212                                                                                                         
          213                    213                 213                                     213             
          214                    214                 214                  214                                    
          215                    215                                                         215             
          216                                                             216                216             
          217                                        217                                     217             
          218                                        218                                     218             
          219                    219                 219                                     219             
          220                    220                 220                  220                    
          221                                                                                                         
          223                                                                                                         
          224                                                                                                         
          228                    228                 228                  228                228             
          229                                                                                                       
          230                    230                 230                  230                230             
          231                    231                 231                  231                231             
          232                                                                                                         
          234                    234                 234                  234                234             
          235                    235                                                                                 
          236                    236                 236                  236                236             
          237                                                                                237             
          238                    238                 238                  238                238             
          239                    239                                      239                239             
          240                    240                 240                  240                240             
          241                    241                                                                                  
          242                    242                                                                                  
          243                                                                                                         
          244                    244                 244                  244                244             
          245                    245                                                                                  
          246                                                                                                         
          247                    247                                                         247             
          248                    248                                                         248             
          249                    249                 249                                     249             
          250                    250                 250                                     250             
          251                    251                 251                  251                251             
          252                    252                                      252                252             
          253                                                                                253             
          254                    254                                                                                  
          255                    255                                                         255             
          256                    256                                                                                  
          257                    257                                                         257             
          258                                                                                                         
          259                    259                 259                  259                259             
          260                    260                                      260                260             
          261                                                                                261             
          262                                                                                                         
          263                                                                                                        
          264                    264                 264                  264                264             
          265                    265                 265                                     265             
          266                    266                 266                  266                266             
          267                    267                 267                  267                267             
          268                                                                                                         
          270                                                                                                         
          271                    271                 271                  271                271             
          273                    273                 273                  273                273             
          274                    274                 274                  274                274             
          275                    275                 275                                                           
          276                    276                 276                  276                276             
          279                    279                 279                  279                279             
          281                    281                 281                  281                281             
          282                    282                 282                  282                282             
          283                    283                 283                  283                283             
          284                    284                 284                  284                284             
          287                    287                 287                  287                287             
          288                    288                                                                                  
          289                    289                 289                  289                289             
          290                                        290                                     290             
          291                    291                 291                  291                291             
          292                    292                 292                  292                292             
          293                    293                                      293                293             
          294                                        294                                     294             
          295                    295                 295                  295                295             
          296                    296                                      296                296             
          297                    297                 297                  297                297             
          300                                                                                                      
          301                    301                 301                  301                301             
          302                                        302                                     302             
          303                    303                 303                  303                303             
          304                    304                 304                  304                304             
          305                    305                 305                  305                305             
          306                    306                 306                  306                306             
     ==============         ==============      ==============       ==============     ==============
Total:    230                    135                 103                   62                112     

Total (unique level count): 235



All solvers failed on these levels: 
===================================================================================
     78      79      89     116     118     125     134     139     140     154 
    182     189     203     204     220     228     230     231     234     236 
    238     240     244     251     259     264     266     267     271     273 
    274     276     279     281     282     283     284     287     289     291 
    292     295     297     301     303     304     305     306 
===================================================================================
Total count: 48


"BOXSEARCH" failed on these levels where at least one solver solved: 
===================================================================================
      4       5      17      20      21      28      29      33      34      36 
     40      41      44      45      48      51      52      53      54      55 
     56      57      58      59      60      61      62      63      64      65 
     66      67      68      69      70      71      72      73      74      75 
     76      77      87      88      90      91      92      93      94      95 
     96      97      98      99     100     101     105     106     107     109 
    111     112     113     114     115     121     122     123     124     126 
    127     129     131     133     136     137     138     141     142     143 
    144     145     146     147     148     150     151     152     153     155 
    156     157     159     161     162     163     164     165     166     167 
    168     169     170     171     172     173     174     175     176     177 
    178     179     180     181     183     184     186     187     188     190 
    191     194     195     196     197     198     199     200     201     202 
    205     206     207     209     210     212     213     214     215     216 
    217     218     219     221     223     224     229     232     235     237 
    239     241     242     243     245     246     247     248     249     250 
    252     253     254     255     256     257     258     260     261     262 
    263     265     268     270     275     288     290     293     294     296 
    300     302 
===================================================================================
Total count: 182


"JSOKO" failed on these levels where at least one solver solved: 
===================================================================================
     44      48      51      55      57      60      62      64      65      66 
     67      68      70      71      72      74      75      76      88      90 
     91      92      97     105     107     111     112     113     124     137 
    138     141     142     146     147     150     155     157     159     165 
    166     168     172     173     175     177     178     179     180     181 
    183     184     186     187     188     190     191     194     195     196 
    205     206     209     213     214     215     219     235     239     241 
    242     245     247     248     249     250     252     254     255     256 
    257     260     265     275     288     293     296 
===================================================================================
Total count: 87


"Sokolution_v301" failed on these levels where at least one solver solved: 
===================================================================================
     55      56      61      62      65      66      68      70      71      74 
     75      76      80      81      82      83      84      90      98      99 
    101     121     124     137     138     142     144     146     147     151 
    155     162     166     175     179     186     187     188     190     194 
    195     202     206     213     214     217     218     219     249     250 
    265     275     290     294     302 
===================================================================================
Total count: 55


"Takaken" failed on these levels where at least one solver solved: 
===================================================================================
     57      71     124     147     150     162     196     214     216     239 
    252     260     293     296 
===================================================================================
Total count: 14


"YASS" failed on these levels where at least one solver solved: 
===================================================================================
      4      44      57      68      70      74      75      77      88      91 
     97     101     105     106     112     129     137     138     141     142 
    150     155     157     166     168     169     170     171     172     174 
    177     178     180     183     186     188     190     191     196     205 
    213     215     216     217     218     219     237     239     247     248 
    249     250     252     253     255     257     260     261     265     290 
    293     294     296     302 
===================================================================================
Total count: 64


"BOXSEARCH" solved these levels where all other solvers failed: 
===================================================================================

===================================================================================
Total count: 0


"JSOKO" solved these levels where all other solvers failed: 
===================================================================================

===================================================================================
Total count: 0


"Sokolution_v301" solved these levels where all other solvers failed: 
===================================================================================
     57     150     196     239     252     260     293     296 
===================================================================================
Total count: 8


"Takaken" solved these levels where all other solvers failed: 
===================================================================================
     68      70      74      75     137     138     142     155     166     186 
    188     190     213     219     249     250     265 
===================================================================================
Total count: 17


"YASS" solved these levels where all other solvers failed: 
===================================================================================
     71     124     147     214 
===================================================================================
Total count: 4


"BOXSEARCH" failed on these levels where all other solvers solved: 
===================================================================================
      5      17      20      21      28      29      33      34      36      40 
     41      45      52      53      54      58      59      63      69      73 
     87      93      94      95      96     100     109     114     115     122 
    123     126     127     131     133     136     143     145     148     152 
    153     156     161     163     164     167     176     197     198     199 
    200     201     207     210     212     221     223     224     229     232 
    243     246     258     262     263     268     270     300 
===================================================================================
Total count: 68


"JSOKO" failed on these levels where all other solvers solved: 
===================================================================================

===================================================================================
Total count: 0


"Sokolution_v301" failed on these levels where all other solvers solved: 
===================================================================================
     80      81      82      83      84 
===================================================================================
Total count: 5


"Takaken" failed on these levels where all other solvers solved: 
===================================================================================

===================================================================================
Total count: 0


"YASS" failed on these levels where all other solvers solved: 
===================================================================================

===================================================================================
Total count: 0

BOXSEARCH solved 76 of 306 levels.

BOXSEARCH 24.8%

JSOKO solved 171 of 306 levels.

JSOKO 55.9%

Sokolution_v301 solved 203 of 306 levels.

Sokolution_v301 66.3%

Takaken solved 244 of 306 levels.

Takaken 79.7%

YASS solved 194 of 306 levels.

YASS 63.4%

All solvers combined solved 258 of 306 levels.

All solvers 84.3%

Solver Statistics - Revenge - Thinking Rabbit

From Sokoban Wiki

Revision as of 14:32, 7 April 2019

Summary of the Sokoban Revenge level set

Summary in a table

Original summary results by Ming

Views

Personal tools

Navigation

Search

Toolbox